The physics, briefly
A resistive element converts one unit of electricity into roughly one unit of heat. A heat pump moves heat from the surrounding air into the water, so it can deliver several units of heat per unit of electricity. That ratio is not fixed: it falls as the air gets colder.
That is why the honest answer to what it will cost is that it depends on where the unit sits, how much hot water you use and what the ambient temperature is through winter.
Where a heat pump makes sense
Households with a geyser in a ventilated position and steady daily hot water use see the most benefit. A unit in a closed, cold cupboard performs worse and is harder to service, which is why siting is part of the specification.
Pool heating is the same principle at a larger scale, and there the cover matters more than the unit. An uncovered pool loses most of the heat you paid for overnight.
Where it does not
If the geyser is tiny, the household is two people using very little hot water, or the only available position is an unventilated internal void, the payback stretches out or disappears. We will tell you that rather than install one anyway.
Whatever the choice, insulation and a geyser blanket are cheaper than either technology. Heat a well-insulated tank with whatever you like.
In short
- — Heat pumps move heat; elements make it. That is the whole difference.
- — Siting and hot water demand decide the real saving.
- — Insulate the tank before upgrading the heat source.